Jonathan Bullard Helps Continue The 11 Year Streak

Rebel plants a second bullet in the head of a gator that kept moving after being hauled into the boat while hunting for alligators near Shell Island, Louisiana on September 20, 2009. Each gator is then tagged before being piled in the bottom of the boat.

I’m not sure I can adequately express my hatred for the University of Florida. Like breathing, I don’t remember when I began, but I know I always have. It feels as old as myself and as irrational as the love for my family and (home) state. I immediately distrust and dislike a person who claims Florida, the state or the school. Because I am a rational person, I bite back that instinct and try—try—to give that person a benefit of doubt. They did not choose to be born in that hell pit of treasonous salt marsh. Perhaps someone held hostage their families for all four years of their enrollment. And yes, it’s easy to say that you’d let your family die rather than go to UF, and maybe you would, but we’re dealing with irrational love versus irrational hate, so who knows what might happen.

Before the game my girlfriend said she understood why I watch football, but she didn’t understand why I allowed myself to invest so much emotional energy in a game that I would be a thousand miles from. I smiled down at her innocent face. I asked her how else she suggested I deal with my feelings of futility and insecurity. I said I must place my feelings of self-doubt, my knowledge of my myriad failures, and the vanishing moments of my life in the hands of young, strong Adonises so they may carry them away for a few hours.

Despite my loathing, I don’t feel defeated or crushed by Saturday’s loss. I’m wounded and disappointed, but my enmity for Florida is undying and I find solace in that. The faces and bodies change, but it is the banner we fight. We will play Florida next year and I will feel the same. There is hope in that.

It might also be learned failure. It’s been 11 years and the memories of victory seem far off and watery.

New coach Jim McElwain said, “I think down deep, you just don’t lose to Tennessee. And they didn’t.” I will never forgive him for that statement. I will spit bile when I speak his name for him saying that. Partially because I’m terrified I’m starting to believe him.

Anyway, there’s a game to talk about.

IN MADDEN I LEARNED NOT TO CALL THE SAME PLAY TWICE

Many have criticized Butch Jones for not going for two when Jalen Hurd scored in the fourth quarter. I understand the frustration and mostly agree. It probably would have been the right call. It is also indicative of the play calling that has plagued UT this year. It is also an easy lightning rod reference point for simple polemics.

The larger play calling issue I saw came on the defensive side of the ball. Nine times on Saturday the Vols decided to play to their weakness rather than their strength by rushing three and spying a defensive end. During the week leading up to the game many writers including Daniel Lewis of Rocky Top Insider argued that a Vol win would include a strong pass rush. Both UT and UF have young offensive lines, but coming into the game it seemed UT might have the edge at defensive line. Florida quarterback Will Grier is an unproven redshirt freshman. The five guys who line up in front of him are green and won’t be making the all-American team. Send five and pray the secondary plays a hair above replacement-level sounded like a solid strategy.

Florida seemed to show up when they needed to most. On first and second downs Tennessee’s defensive line hurried Grier and dealt with running back Kevin Taylor pretty well. On those downs Jones and defensive coordinator John Jancek sent at least four linemen after Grier, often sending an extra man from different linebacker, safety, or corner. The moved pass rushing powerhouse Derek Barnett around the line to good effect, and for most of the game Barnett and Corey Vereen could be found toasting the men trying to block them. This worked out well and helped the Vols amass a lead.

Through four games it is pretty clear that the strength of the Tennessee defense is not the secondary. At worst the DBs look like Cameron Sutton and a bunch of guys wearing the same clothes, and at best it’s a serviceable position group capable of making one or two plays per game. If you watch the front seven, you’ll notice they usually control how the DBs look. When Barnett, Vereen, Reeves-Maybin and Co. are rushing the passer, that’s when the DBs don’t look like dumb dogs chasing smart cats.

But Jones and Jancek changed the scheme when they had UF facing 3rd or 4th and long. On nine of the 13 times the Vols had the Gators six or more yards behind the eight ball, they ran the same scheme: Two D-lineman and one defensive end would rush after Grier while the second defensive end spied Grier in case he scrambled.

4&14

Most of the time only rushing three basically worked. Six of those nine plays resulted in UF failing to achieve a 1st down. But this was mainly due to how incredible Barnett and the defensive line looked in this game. Even rushing three, Grier was forced out of the pocket and into hurried throws. A couple times the Gators’ O-line was badly beaten and Grier was only able to throw the ball away a split-second before being sacked. It isn’t absurd to think that had UT rushed four, some of those incompletions would be sacks.

3&14

In trying to Band Aid the gaping holes in the secondary, Tennessee not only made their defense weaker overall, but also they became predicable. In Florida’s last seven 3rd/4th and long situations Tennessee only rushed four once. They preferred to run a rush three, spy one prevent defense. They ran this scheme on UF’s game winning pass play. As they had on the play directly before it. As they had on the previous drive with UF facing 4th and 8. As they had 70% of the time the Gators were in similar situations. When Florida’s game was on the line with 4th and 14 to go, Jim McElwain could comfortably assume that his QB would only face three rushers.

Grier had time. He made the throw. The secondary was out of position, which should surprise no one. The execution of the play wasn’t good, and it’s easy to blame one play, especially when it’s the play that decides the game, but the fault is on the predictable pattern of play. Tennessee’s defense did not collapse. Florida figured it out.

JONATHAN BULLARD DOES A PRETTY GOOD JJ WATT IMPRESSION

Last week I almost wrote about #71 Dylan Wiesman and the offensive line’s woes. Instead I decided to watch the line closely week game, and, dear god, it was a horror show.

#90 Jonathan Bullard, defensive lineman for the University of Florida, found this aimless group of young men calling themselves tackles and guards, and decided to eat them alive while they flailed their hands in his face.

Bullard set the tone of the game and was behind nearly every decisive play against the UT offense. Officially he recorded eight tackles, including three for loss and one sack, but that does not fully describe the way the manhandled the Tennessee linemen.

Early in the second quarter, Tennessee ran the ball well, but Ballard wore on the line, pushing them around. On one power run, #63 Brett Kendrick was burdened with Bullard. His job was to derail Bullard as the center and guard kicked out to block for Hurd at the edge. But Bullard was a quick step ahead of everyone. Instead of being derailed he pushed Kendrick back into the center and guard. The play still went for two yards, but dealing with Bullard all day was a nagging problem that added to the feeling that the game might tilt in Florida’s favor at any moment.

Bullard everyday

Bullard had more impressive plays than this one in the first half of the game, but I think this play illustrates best how he disrupted the game on each snap he played. Tennessee’s young and unsure O-linemen knew each time Bullard launched from his stance he would be faster and stronger. He would be in better position and quicker. Think of fighting with a prime-aged, vicious but toothless, pit bull for 30 minutes. The dog isn’t going to kill or maim you, but he is going to lunge at and ram and bulrush you. You’ll have to bend and try to catch him while he twists around you. Your muscles will ache from trying to hold him. You’ll bruise from where he hits you, where you fall. His bald gums will clamp your arms and push them against your chest. After a while, you’ll just want to give up because the dog is better at fighting that you. It’s okay. No one expected you to be better than him, you’ll tell yourself.

I assume that’s what blocking Jonathan Bullard was like on Saturday.

I assume that’s how #71 Dylan Wiesman felt between the Florida scoring drives in the fourth quarter as UT tried to run the ball and hold on to a six-point lead. On 1st down Coleman Thomas hiked the ball and Bullard rammed Wiesman a couple yard into the backfield so when Jalen Hurd ran by Bullard tossed Wiesman aside and tackled Hurd.

Bullard 4th

I assume both Wiesman and Kirkland were nearly crippled by fatigue and frustration when a play later on a crucial 3rd and 6, Bullard pushed both linemen back into Dobbs’ path during a designed QB run. Bottled up, Dobbs found himself three yards behind the line of scrimmage and in the meeting place of three colliding bodies.

bullard last

When UT led, it was easy to overlook the havoc Bullard wreaked on the line because he wasn’t sacking Dobbs or tackling Hurd for huge losses, but as the game wore on and got closer in points, it became clear that the offensive line was beleaguered and gassed. Bullard’s constant harassment and near misses became suddenly visible as big stops and momentum shifts.

JOSH DOBBS AND JALEN HURD DON’T NEED AN OFFENSIVE LINE

Tennessee ran for 254 yards against Florida. They ran 51 times for an average of five yards per carry. Both Dobbs and Hurd surpassed 100 yards. Most of the time, that means that the offensive line played well and set up two pretty talented players for success. From time to time that was true in this game. During the first half while the O-line was still fresh, there were some moments of hope and promise. The first play from scrimmage was well blocked and Hurd took advantage with a 16-yard run.

More often the offensive line looked out of sorts and particularly bad while power blocking. Early in the game Dobbs handed the ball to Hurd from the shotgun. It was a power run to the edge. #75 Marcus Jackson and #71 Wiesman stepped back and pulled to become the lead blockers at the edge—a pretty run of the mill power run—but instead of hitting the corner at roughly the same time Hurd did, Jackson ran into the back of another lineman then Wiesman ran into him, like a three-car pile up. Hurd found the edge filled with Gators. Unfortunately this play is emblematic of the failings of the offensive line this year.

Most often Dobbs and Hurd bailed out their offensive line with open field heroics and pure speed. They shrugged off and juked away from defenders all day. They ignored terrible blocks and missed assignments. Hurd constantly found his running lanes filled with Gators and was forced to find the edge. Because he is an excellent athlete, he was able to muscle out decent gains on the outside. Dobbs’ rushes are much the same story. Too many came after dodging defenders streaking into the backfield. I can’t say Dobbs looked good throwing the ball, but he bailed out the offence with his feet often enough to make me think there’s no better option.

It seems clear that Butch Jones understands that his offensive line lacks . . . well . . . just lacks the things—aside from big bodies—are needed to play offensive line. If we look at UT’s biggest offensive plays from the game, we see that they are all designed to make up for those failings.

Tennessee’s first score was on a double pass designed to get the entire defense on one side of the field. Dobbs passed to Juan Jennings, the defense swarmed to that side, Jennings passed the ball back to Dobbs, and he ran to the end zone more or less uncontested. The job of the offensive line on this play is better described as “getting in the way” than “blocking.”

doub;e pass

Dobbs’ 62-yard run in the final minutes of the first half came on a designed quarterback draw. This play also limited the importance of the offensive line. Here most linemen needed only nudge defensive linemen as they streak past so Dobbs could run by them before the linemen could adjust. Despite the design of the play, Wiesman still managed to miss his block at the second level. Because Josh Dobbs is an intrepid hero, he spun Gator LB Antonio Morrison out of his shoes.

Dobbs big run

To Butch Jones’ credit, he tailored the offensive game plan to his runners’ strengths. Trick plays, screens, and draws are obvious bright spots, but this game also featured much more read-option. With Dobbs at QB, Jones has always run the read-option, but he’s mixed it with a healthy amount of passing (because in theory we have very talented receivers). The read-option is designed to keep the defense off-balance to make up for poor line play, which is why we saw so much of it against Florida. As much as I’m annoyed with the completely predictable defensive game plan that did highlighted the defense’s weakness, I’m pleased that Butch Jones seems to be adapting to his quarterback’s anxiety in the pocket and his offensive line’s sub-par performance.

The Case for Trevor Daniel

catamount

On Saturday the Vols lined up and played something that looked like football against something called Western Carolina University. This was not an exciting game. WCU was paid $500,000 to come to Knoxville to get knocked around. At one point the commentators noted how good the money would be for WCU. Catamount Head Coach Mark Speir said, “A game like this will send 32 football players to school at Western Carolina.”

In the wake of the loss to OU, it’s nice to think that the University of Tennessee is making 32 lives a little better.

Discerning anything from a game against an FCS opponent is nearly impossible. Coaches tend to run vanilla schemes and base formations in these kinds of game. As was said many times throughout Saturday’s matchup, the game was to evaluate fundamentals and give understudies a chance to play something that resembles a real game. It’s also pretty easy to imagine that the starters were looking ahead to the game against Florida next week. Given that, I don’t want to dwell on any major parts of the game. I didn’t see much that would add or detract from my evaluation of the team after the Oklahoma game.

Instead I would like to make:

The Case for Trevor Daniel

Trevor Hover

Punters aren’t guys who get noticed. There are many unsung positions on a football team. More often than not a less than rabid fan won’t notice an offensive lineman until a lineman is called for holding. Even rabid fans would have a hard time naming the common special teams players beyond the kickers and returners. But punters occupy an odd space. We know their names but other than in extreme cases, we don’t notice them or even know when to notice them.

The punter is the only player that no one wants. The punter enters play when a team has failed. His only job is to give the ball to the other team. His entire person is surrender. I’m writing about the position, and even I hope that UT doesn’t punt once next week. A team scoring points has no reason to punt. So we spurn the punter.

But why? We know that football is a game of field position. We know that punting is part of the game, but many of us have thought, “just go for it” a hundred more times than we’ve thought, “this is a good place to punt.” And when we have thought about the merits of deciding to give the other team the ball, most often those thoughts are compensatory. It is a concession judged in terms of how much worse it could be.

It doesn’t help that we judge the merit of a punter by yardage. It’s comical that in the day of sabermetrics and smart fans, we still judge a guy solely by how far he can kick a ball. This should annoy us as much as when we hear a QB praised just because he has a strong arm. (I’m nearly certain that Tyler Bray has a much stronger arm than Peyton Manning, but whom would you rather have? For anything? Even if it were a backyard rock throwing competition, wouldn’t you rather chance losing to hangout with Manning rather than probably win and hangout with Bray?)

A strong leg is good. I don’t dispute that when kicking from your own twelve, you want a guy who can kick the hell out of the pig. Obviously the same logic isn’t true forty yards up field. The goodness of a seventy-yard punt is wholely based on a team’s field position. So lets talk about giving up and lets talk about a man who is great at giving the other team the ball.

I give you Trevor “White Elephant” Daniel. Daniel is #93 in your program and #1 in your hearts because if UT is going to give the ball to the other team you want Mr. Daniel to do it. A punt from Mr. Daniel is a burdensome gift that no one really wants.

Trevor

White Elephant hails from Dickson, TN, a small suburb of Nashville. At Dickson County High he kicked (punter), caught (tight end), and sacked (defensive end) his way to letterman status for three years. Daniel is majoring in Recreation and Sports Management, which means he plans on being drafted into the NFL.

Currently Daniel’s average punt goes for 47.6 yards. That’s good enough for 2nd in the SEC. That is a pretty nice average through three games, but judging by this traditional criterion, Daniel is far behind the fist place spot. In first is Texas A&M’s Drew Kaser. On ten punts Kaser averages a booming 52.7 yards. That’s a pretty insane number. Kaser has a rocket launcher for a leg. If punting were actually a distance competition, we’d have a winner.

We don’t have a winner. We have a guy who can kick a ball very far. We have the leg version of Tyler Bray. Do you want Tyler Bray at your barbeque? You know he’s going to drink too much and rip his shirt off. He’s going to point to the tattoo on his back and scream, “What’s it say?! What’s it say?!” Nobody wants that. You know what else no one wants? To start a drive inside their own twenty-yard line.

The cliché is football is a game of field position. Gaudy stats are nice. Eighty-yard drives are time consuming and wearing on the other team’s defense, but if the offense drove eighty yards from their own ten, it’s not quite as good as driving thirty yards from the other team’s seventy. One (probably) results in a field goal and the other in a touchdown. We should look at punts the same way. A fifty yard punt doesn’t help if your offense is at the opponent’s 49.

So if the point of punting is to put the other team in the worst possible position lets judge punters by how disadvantageous the position they leave the opposing team in is. Instead of the average distance, we’ll judge punters by the opposing team’s average starting position after the punt.

I’ll start with the reigning leader in the SEC, Drew Kaser. In Kaser’s ten punts he has pinned his opponents inside their own 20 four times, leaving them to start at their 11, 13, 14, and 6 yard lines. He’s forced them to start at the 20 once. Otherwise he’s left them starting okay at the 36, 37, 25, 40, and 38. That comes to an average starting field position of 24. Starting from the 24-yard line isn’t great but certainly sounds far less scary than a punter who averages 52 yards per punt.

We need context for this number. It works out well that the SEC’s middle of the pack punter is Florida’s Johnny Townsend. Townsend is averaging 41.4 yards per punt. That puts him eighth out of the fifteen punters in the SEC who’ve punted at least three times. (It’s not exactly the middle, but we’re playing Florida next week so I’m going to use him because of that.) Townsend has punted twelve times and pinned his opponents inside the 20 twice (8, 2). Offenses have been left to start from the 20 twice. His other punts have varied widely (22, 26, 27, 30, 31, 34, 43, 48). If you’re playing against Florida you can expect your average start to be seventy-four yards from pay dirt. That is the 26-yard line. So the leader by average distance is only two yards better than the middle of the pack punter by average starting position.

Trevor 2

Maybe forcing an opponent to start at their own 24 is good. Maybe we live in a world where that is the best as can hope for as we cede position to our foes. Friends we do not live in that world. Those who don orange and white, you have a hero with a leg like a pendulum that swings with mathematical accuracy! Trevor Daniel is that hero. Daniel is by no means weak legged. He has boomed a couple of sixty-one yard punts. What is most thrilling is his touch, his ability to arc the ball into the air and drop it inside the opponent’s 20. Daniel has done this eight times (12, 9, 3, 14, 6, 11, 11, 6) Eight times in sixteen punts. That Daniel is placing the ball inside the 20 half the time he punts is amazing, but add to that the range of these kicks. The distance of those eight punts ranges from thirty-four to fifty-two yards, which should clearly illustrate the intentionality of his kicks. He’s pegging the opposing offense in the shadow of their goal posts from all over the field. In Daniel’s other kicks he’s twice put the ball at the 20. Otherwise his kicks have left teams at the 22, 26, 26, 44, 40, and 31. Those starts beyond the 20 include the two times he has launched a ball sixty-one yards to leave it at the 26. If you’ve done the math, Daniel is forcing teams to start from the 19-yard line, on average. That is five yards farther back than average distance leader Kaser and seven yards better than middle of the roader and next week’s opposing punter Townsend.

And that, my friends, turns out to be a pretty big difference. Teams starting from the 20-yard line score some points about a little less than a quarter of the time. This year a good SEC punter puts his defense in position to only give up points a little more than one in four times, about 26%. Trevor “White Elephant” Daniel puts the Vols defense in position to give up points one in five times. Yes, stats bear out that teams starting inside their own 20-yard line score only 20% of the time. A quarter versus a fifth. That is a pretty nice edge.

In short, go here. Type “93” then “Daniel.” Click “Add to Cart” and buy. Pull the jersey over your head and pretend your leg is a pendulum of field advantage that leaves your foes in a pit of woe.

Mayfield Never Tasted So Sour

 

TKj

When Tennessee lined up on Saturday against Oklahoma, I’d left the storm of dread I’d worked up during the week on the subway. Last season OU drubbed the Vols 34-10. Trevor Knight and Sterling Shepard threw a party in the UT secondary. Knight laughed and danced in his home stadium while the Vols’ defense stuttered and chased, perpetually a step behind. That was a different world. We still lived in a Justin Worley world. This was a new season with new life and Josh Dobbs. Vegas had Oklahoma as a 1-point favorite, and given last year, I was happy with that.

We all have a right to hope. No matter what we can jump and reach our arms in the air for the ball. We can believe and hope that we will be tall enough. That we’ve made mistakes, but this once we will be great. We will save the day.

Some might say it’s the hope, the ability to dream of that which will be better that is important. Because hope can get a person through very, very hard times.

Lets get on with this.

 

Tennessee opened the game well. Sophomore Todd Kelly Jr. stretched his hands out in the right place at the right time. Mayfield—that Mayfield dairy products are a Tennessee tradition and a big part of my childhood is not lost on me, and you can assume that typing the Sooners’ heroic QB’s name gives me a special twinge of pain today; imagine your kid sister stealing your girlfriend, it’s like that—Mayfield sailed a pass that bounced off Dede Westbrook’s hands. Kelly Jr. let the ball fall into his hands as he stumbled.

The Vols took over at the 50 and ran read-option to success. UT’s third play from scrimmage proved ominous. Dobbs lined up in the shotgun. The ball snapped and he bounced on his feet nervously. The line held and gave him time to read the field. Dobbs felt the phantom of pressure. He ran out of the pocket toward the OU sideline. This allowed #92 Matthew Romar to peel off UT center Coleman Thomas’ block. He chased after Dobbs. Dobbs ended up running directly to star linebacker Eric Striker. Dobbs threw an off target pass incomplete to avoid getting blasted by the appropriately named linebacker. This was only the third play in a big game from a second year QB. These things happen in the beginning of games. Andrew Luck has made a career of playing only okay football until he becomes an unstoppable, intrepid hero. (As I write this, the Colts trail the Bills 24-0, and I have no doubt that Luck will find a way to win the game, and more or less by himself.)

dobbs hurried

Dobbs’ hurried scrambling and flittering under pressure became a theme of the game. On a couple occasions twitter and the commentators gave props to Dobbs for stepping up in the pocket or taking a shot as he threw, but there was good reason for those plays to stand out as strikingly different. In the first quarter while the UT O-line stood tall on passing plays and Dobbs was able to execute scripted one-read plays, he looked capable and decisive. His touchdown pass to Josh Malone was a great example of how good Dobbs can be when things go as planned. For much of the second quarter Dobbs played well. He ran the read-option about as well as anyone could ask. What’s concerning is how Dobbs reacted when his first read wasn’t available or when the pocket caved in.

The second half of the game was a blur of oncoming pass rushers for both Dobbs and Mayfield. Both QBs dealt with collapsing pockets and missed blocks. The difference between their performances predicted the difference in the game. Mayfield scrambled away from linemen and blitzing linebackers, holding the ball until Tennessee’s suspect coverage broke down. Dobbs did not.

From the beginning of the second half Dobbs scrambled at the first sign of pressure. He was terrible through the entire second part of the game, completing 5 of 14 passes for 51 yards before overtime. Oklahoma smelled Dobbs’ nervous sweat and sent blitzing corners and linebackers. This wore on the offensive line down, which then crumbled further. To Dobbs’ credit, he had every reason to sweat. He was hurried on most of his throws, but even when he wasn’t, it seemed that he expected to be.

I’m more than a little worried about what this means for the season. Dobbs surely isn’t going to have it much easier facing SEC defensives as Florida, Arkansas, and Alabama are all currently in the top 20. But we hope. Oh, we can hope. There’s also reason to hope. Dobbs and Hurd run the read-option beautifully. Sure it would be nice to do something with Marquez North, Von Pearson, and Pig Howard, and Josh Malone, and Ethan Wolf, but the read-option is a good place to start. It’s only that hope opened a broadsword-sized wound in me that I sound like I’m giving up hope for Dobbs. I am certainly not. I’m just asking that he calm down a bit.

 

Let me for a moment act as if I am very good at analyzing data and steal some metrics from Advanced Football Analytics.

On their first possession, Tennessee drove to the OU 1-yard line. On third down Coach Jones replaced Jalen Hurd with Alvin Kamara. Some questioned this, but I’m totally willing to assume all the good arguments about fresh legs and changes of pace are totally valid. What I cannot agree with, what I cannot understand is Jones’ decision to KICK A FIELD GOAL FROM THE ONE-YARD LINE. I am not the first person to talk about this logic. Grantland, The New York Times, and Football Outsiders have all written extensively about this.

So lets add to the wealth of examples of how the math proves kicking a field goal from inside the five is boneheaded. Tennessee was at the 1-yard line—actually they were inside the 1-yard line, but I’m just going to call it the one. It was fourth down. I’m going to be generous to Coach Jones and say that he had a 60% change of picking up that one yard (the actual percentage is probably closer to 70). If they get it, they score. That’s 7 points. (Yes, I am going to assume that the PAT is good.) When we subtract the estimated value of the starting field position OU will have after the kick-off that is actually worth 6.3 points. (Go here and here if you need primers on EP).

So right now I’m telling you that 60% of the time Tennessee goes for it here they will get what translates to 6.3 points. But we live in terror of that other 40%! In that other 40% OU will have a first down on their own 1-yard line. Trust me on this, that position on the field is worth about -1.5 points. If you’re having trouble here just note that there is a minus sign before the number. That is bad. Also note that 6.3 is much greater than -1.5.

Here’s how we run the math so you can do it at home while you scream at the TV.

 

(Percentage of getting the 1st/scoring * Expected Points)+((1 – Percentage of getting the 1st/scoring) * the opponent’s EP if the attempt fails)=The Expected Value of The Going for It

 

Got it? Yeah it took me like five hours.

So for you Coach Jones:

 

(.60 * 6.3) + ((1 – .60) * -1.5)= 3.18

 

So the value of the play, of going for it averages to 3.18 points, which, just to be clear, is more than the points rewarded for a successful field goal.

I am also not accounting for the full context. Jones’ had a fresh O-line that had played mere minutes of football. Jones’ also has Jalen Hurd. This year Hurd has averaged 4.9 yards per carry. And if you think that’s because he’s only faced one real defense this year, last year he averaged 4.4 yards. Again, so the math is clear, 4.4 is much greater than 1, as in the one yard to the end zone.

Coaches scoff at this like Americans scoff at the metric system. And it’s just as dumb.

 

It would be far too simplistic to say that the goal line call in the 1st quarter was the difference in the game. (Although, I might argue the it is indicative of other coaching decisions that are more relevant to the final score.) Not going for it on 4th down didn’t cause a complete defensive collapse.

At moments in the first half of the game it appeared as if Butch Jones had fixed the secondary. The coverage was tight and everyone seemed to be, usually, in the right place, which is not something UT fans expect at this point. But very early in the game there was a moment that glimpsed into what would come in the 4th quarter. Oddly enough it was the Sooners’ first offensive play after the UT field goal.

better 13 burned

Mayfield sent running back Joe Mixon out with the WRs and took the snap in an empty backfield shotgun. The Vols rushed four successfully. Derek Barnett marry-go-rounded Cody Ford, who held on for the ride. Mayfield escaped the pocket. UT looked like they were playing some sort of cover 2. Mixon created an imbalance, leaving three OU WRs to two UT DBs. DBs ran tight with their men. Mixon blew by a man I’d like to showcase in a moment, #13 Malik Foreman. Foreman appeared confused as to whether he should cover Mixon or the WR. Mixon blew by him and there was nothing but grass before him. Mayfield hit him with an easy pass. Luckily, Cody Ford was still holding on to Barnett like squirrel on a crop duster. The play came back, but Scramble until the Coverage Collapses was a play OU would come back to later.

 

The fourth quarter was littered with moments that the Vols lost their focus and fundamentals as the play developed. Tennessee’s front four chased Mayfield out of the pocket and most of his throws were hurried or on the run. Even if that worked out for OU, harassing the guys like Mayfield is a good thing. Behind the front four things didn’t work out so well. Spying linebackers found themselves out of position and confused after Mayfield escaped, allowing him to throw and run for big gains.

Mayfield consistently scrambled and waited until UT’s secondary broke down. OU’s first touchdown is a place where the defense’s copper shows through the polish. Safety Brain Randolph was in charge of containing Mayfield. Mayfield scrambled out of the pocket toward the sideline, with RB Samaje Perine running above him. Fan favorite and part-time hero Jalen Reeves-Maybin covered Perine. Mayfield ran waiting for his spy to charge, so as to be unable to help defend the throw. In the same moment Reeves-Maybin stepped toward the QB while Perine slid into the end zone. This left Reeves-Maybin in no man’s land where he was unable to make a play on the throw or on the catch. It also helps that unlike Dobbs, Mayfield looks as if he likes throwing the ball amid defensive players.

 

I don’t subscribe to the idea that one player can cost a team victory. Losing is a team effort. A bunch of people have to do a bunch of things wrong to give up a 17 point lead.

That said, sometimes a player will try as hard as he can to prove that it is possible to make losing an individual effort. Saturday’s game had such a singular player, and I think it would be a disservice to him not to single out such a performance.

Let us praise #13 Malik Foreman. Foreman hails from Kingsport, TN, a place near and dear to my heart. He played his HS ball at Dobyns-Bennett. On Saturday if you were screaming at a screen, it’s almost certain that Foreman was on it.

I already noted that Foreman blew his coverage on the nixed play I described above. You may remember Foreman from the fourth quarter when he plowed into WR A.D. Miller as Miller waited for a pass in the back of the end zone. Brad Nessler posited that Foreman had no idea where he was on the field. I think he knew exactly where he was. He saw both Millers’ hands go out for the ball and Foreman thought, “DOUBLE HIGHFIVE!” Memories of spending his birthday alone in Burger King flashed. He heard his mother’s voice say, “Maybe they forgot, honey.” The helmet on his head felt like a cheap paper crown. He sped up and raised his hands in brotherly love.

13 Highfive

If you don’t remember that moment, which resulted in a PI call that gave OU 1st & 10 from UT’s 15, maybe you’ll remember him from the Sooners’ last offensive play. You remember it’s the play that ended in Sterling Shepard twisting his body into the end zone. He stood alone when he caught the ball, and maybe you thought, someone should be covering that guy. That someone was our hero Malik Foreman. You might have missed him because HE FELL DOWN. Right off the line his legs got tangled with Shepard’s. He falls down and OU scores.

13 for the lose

Hats off to you Mr. Foreman. Get the number 13 tattooed on your neck because you were born to wear it.

PS. The Colts lost to the Bills 27-14.

Dobbs Season

Dobbs under center

Saturday was the first time in years that I’ve been actually excited for the Tennessee Volunteers’ season opener. These past years have not been the most exciting to be a Vol fan. For the first time in what feels like a generation the Vols are being called a sleeper team. After seven years of watching the team fail to win more than seven games, being called a sleeper team is like being told there might be an office pizza party. You’ve been down and broken for so long that just the chance of something positive to talk about is literally thrilling.

The Vols opened in Nashville against Bowling Green. While they soundly defeated the well-compensated—BGSU received 1.2 million dollars for showing up—Falcons by 29 points, the game probably did more to show us how Tennessee is weak than how it is strong.

But First #11 Josh Dobbs.

I will not apologize for my adoration. I will not curtail my love, hope, the beams of light that shine from my eyes as I type this sentence about the one, the only, Robert Joshua Dobbs. I do not care. Grantland’s Mallory Rubin picked Dobbs to win the Heisman. That is all the vindication I need to run with. And I will run FOR EVER, like Josh Dobbs stepping up, tucking the ball, and running through the defensive line into the secondary, juking a safety, and sprinting into the end zone to win all the games at once.

Seriously, this is probably the way every orange-blooded Tennessee fan should feel. After watching three years of Tyler Bray struggle to complete 60% of his passes, two years of Jonathan Crompton dress-up as a QB, and three years of Erik Ainge . . . well actually Ainge had a pretty good run from 06–07. But that was the last time Tennessee won more than seven games. For more context, Ainge was throwing to guys like Robert Meachem and Lucas Taylor and handing-off to Montario Hardesty (remember when he was going to be great for the Browns??) and Arian Foster. All these guys are nearly 30. Robert Meachem has completed a middle of the road NFL career. Arian Foster has run for 6300 yards and 53 touchdowns since then. (Hardesty ran for 537 yards and one touchdown, but in my heart he is always running away from Jonathan Crompton.)

Josh Dobbs is a beacon of light in the endless absence of God’s light. When I read Milton’s description of grace, I see Josh Dobbs’ arm flow forward and release a divine strike of a pass to a wide-open Von Pearson.

Last night against BGSU, Dobbs completed 68% of his passes and averaged 9 yards per completion. Obviously Bowling Green is not an SEC level defense, but these numbers aren’t the normal type of inflated stats we see in tune-up games. (Remember in 2012 when Tyler Bray completed 90% of his passes for 310 yards and 4 touchdowns against Georgia State?) Dobbs took the slack in Falcons’ defense, which was mostly in the run game. Dobbs looked confident and in control even at the beginning of the game. You might think that should always be the case, but that would also mean you haven’t watched much UT football. Dobbs missed a couple easy throws in the first quarter, most notably when he badly underthrew a screen to WR Josh Smith. What the stats won’t show are the two times in the first quarter Dobbs drew BGSU offside with impressive hard counts. In a 29-point win those things don’t seem to matter, but they speak to something much larger. Actively trying to trick the defense and draw them offside, working on that skill in a tune-up game the same way any QB works on his reads and throws speaks to what UT has been missing under center for years. Ainge, Crompton, Bray, and Worley all had every physical tool a coach could ask for. I’m extrapolating a little here, but I think that Dobbs working on his hard counts and getting the Falcons’ line to jump is the kind of thing that we all tend to overlook. It’s those little things that add up. It’s those things we miss or forget and when we try to account for them we simply say that a QB “knows how to win.” It’s that kind of cunning that Tennessee has missed while it lined up a guy who had his own named tattooed on his back.

shoefatigue.0

Speaking of the Bowling Green Defensive line, let us pause to consider NG #54, Mike Minns. It’s not what he did during a play but what he did after. Bowling Green was down 11 points with UT inside the five-yard line. I can only imagine what it feels like to face an 18-point deficit in real life on regional TV. Minns lost his shoe during a 1st & Goal run. As Dobbs rushed to get UT to the line, Minns raced toward the sideline waving his shoe in the air. He was panicked. Then calm rushed over his face. He realized that his team was never supposed to win. Winning is not why they’d traveled to Nashville. All the pep talks, all the motivational speeches Dino Babers yelled at top volume echoed hallow in Minns’ ears. Rattled and replete with insight, he let go. He let his knees buckle and fell back into the soft turf and for a moment there was silence and sky. He was back in West Palm Beach years ago when he’d played football to escape the realities of living in Florida. He was back staring up into the sky, as he’d done long after everyone else had left the field, long after he’d beaten them all.

Jalen Hurd and Alvin Kamara both had a great night. Kamara looked like he’s capable of living up to his hype as a speedster. I’m extremely excited to see how this duo works out together. But I want to see what they look like when they face an elite defensive line. Bowling Green got some pressure on Dobbs, but they seemed to completely checkout in the run game. Last year Hurd looked like a star in the making, and I think he is, but I want to wait until I see him play against a couple of top tier defenses before I call him such. Same with Kamara, for whom I have even less to go on. That said, I’m pretty psyched to watch these two run against an Oklahoma defense that gave up 138 rushing yard to a team they beat 41-3 last night, and allowed 106 yards per game last year.

However that might not matter given that Tennessee allowed BGSU to gain 557 yards Saturday night and showed off some pretty glaring holes in the secondary. UT got scorched for 433 yards in the air and let WR Gehrig Dieter tear past them for 133 yards and a touchdown on seven catches. On the surface it looks as if Dieter toasts DB Emmanuel Mosley. It’s pretty fun to think of CB vs. WR as a one-on-one battle with the most talented and tenacious man winning, but isn’t the case in college football and is only rarely the case in the NFL. So in the second quarter when it looked like Dieter whisked past the charred corpse of Mosley, that was not exactly the case. On the play Mosley played close and tried to jam Dieter at the line. Dieter got past and ended up side-by-side with Mosley in a footrace everyone knew Mosley would lose. Mosley only allowed this to happen because he expected Brain Randolph to be in over the top support. As the ball arced through the air we saw Randolph rushing toward the sideline at a bad angle because he was caught out of position. Matt Johnson caught the defense out of position in same way on the next play. Mosley tried to jam Dieter and lost and it was Evan Berry’s turn to leave Mosley out on a burning limb. Surely Butch Jones saw this and will mend the still smoldering holes in his secondary.

The defensive line also made a valiant effort to play half a game. The front four looked good against straightforward runs, but were easily confused by draws, screens, and options. That’s not really great. Watching the film it’s pretty clear that Tennessee’s defensive line can physically dominate BGSU’s o-line, but they were out maneuvered and out coached, which is probably much worse than being pushed around. The pass rush is nearly the same story. When the defense sent a blitzing linebacker Johnson was hurried and at best threw an incompletion. This worked well if Johnson didn’t have a receiver in the flat. When Johnson did have a route in the flat, UT’s linebackers seemed shocked and taken by surprise, as if the TE or RB had teleported behind them. Again this is not ideal. It’s not as if flat routes are uncommon or archaic. Worst of all is that these errors led to the Falcons’ biggest plays of the game. UT was caught off guard for big plays on third and fourth down when the defense should have been getting off the field. Vols fans should be very wary of this. These are the plays that we dealt with all last year as we watched the defense keep the door cracked open until one big play set off the avalanche that buried us.